Choosing the Right Shingle
3-Tab vs. Architectural Shingles
Asphalt shingles are the most popular roofing material in the US. They are easy to install and a less expensive option, making them an easy choice for many Americans. There are two types of asphalt shingles on the market: the traditional 3-tab shingle and the more high-end architectural shingle.
3-Tab Shingles
Looks
- 3 tabs are cut on the lower edge of the shingle, making it look like each is an individual shingle when installed.
Durability
- Lighter weight so more vulnerable to curling and damage. Recommended for low sloping roofs that are at risk of wind driven rains.
Weight / Wind Resistance
- 240 lbs/square
- wind speeds up to 60 mph
Warranty
- About 25 years
Advantages
- Easy Install
- Less Expensive
Architectural Shingles
Looks
- Can be made to look like premium roofing materials like slate or cedar. Hide more imperfections.
Durability
- Nearly double the thickness of 3-tab—less vulnerable to damage and curling because they are laminated with an additional asphalt layer.
Weight / Wind Resistance
- 340 – 440 lbs/square
- 80-120 mph
Warranty
- 40 – 50 years
Advantages
- More color and style options
- Resistance to hail
- Higher resistance to fire
- Can withstand extreme temperatures
Our analysis of the options
Architectural shingles cost 30 – 40% more than 3 tab shingles because they are considered a more high-end roofing product. While they are more expensive up front, they often end up being a better choice over time because they are more durable and have longer warranties.
To find out more about your roofing options in the Columbia, SC area, contact Seawright Roofing at 1-803-828-4181.